Big Orange Flapper | Noels Plumbing Supply

“Eljer 495-6031 Toilet Flapper” has been added to your cart. View cart

Bright orange rubber with stainless chain.

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY…

“Just wanted to thank you for the great service, quality product, and fast shipping, we appreciate all of it. Best, Rod S. ”

-Rod S.

11/11/2023

$14.87

The Wolverine Brass 51164 is a “Big Orange” premium toilet tank flapper designed for 3.5 gallon flush valves. It is known for its durability and resistance to harsh water conditions.

We can ship anywhere the US Postal Service ships. For orders being shipped outside the US, please contact us at (888) ASK-NOEL, noelsplumbingsupply@fuse.net, or via the text widget on this screen.

Share on:

Wolverine Big Orange Toilet Flapper

Heavy Wolverine rubber, yet flexible enough for positive seal
Stainless no kink chain assembly
Antioxidant treated silicone orange rubber resists deterioration
Built-in overflow tube adapter included
It fits all standard 2-inch plastic and brass flush valves.

51164

Customer submitted images.

Common questions about this product

Yes, this is the OEM recommended part.

If you’re not sure text us a picture 1-888-275-6635 or email us a picture at noelsplumbingsupply@fuse.net.

We will make sure you have the right part.

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY…

“These people were extremely helpful in taking me through replacing a 25 year old hard water frozen cartridge on my Philrich sink faucet. They were able to identify the correct part I needed from a photo I sent (I had it figured out wrong). I was pleasantly surprised they had an obscure part like this, but they also told me how to extract the old one when I couldn’t get it out. They said to unscrew it after I had concluded from YouTube the old cartridge was supposed to just slide out. It threaded out as they said and saved me buying a cartridge extractor and a hernia. The whole experience has been excellent. ”

-Pete L.

03/10/2026